March 29, 1974. Sha Na Na showed up on The Midnight Special — NBC’s late-night music show where everything was performed live. No playback. No do-overs. Just you and the song. And the song they chose? Already 15 years old. “A Teenager in Love,” first recorded by Dion and the Belmonts back in 1959, hit #5 on the Billboard Hot 100. Everybody knew it. Everybody had their own memory of it. So when Chico stepped up to sing lead, most people probably figured they knew exactly what they were going to hear. They were wrong. Dave “Chico” Ryan didn’t just cover it — he felt every word. His voice was warm, a little rough, completely honest. Behind him, tight harmonies, greaser jackets, and a band that once played Woodstock right before Hendrix, when they’d only done 8 shows in their lives. Fifteen years after Dion first sang it, Chico made that old heartbreak feel real all over again.
When Sha Na Na Brought “A Teenager in Love” to The Midnight Special On March 29, 1974, Sha Na Na…