SMOKEY ROBINSON WROTE “MY GIRL” FOR THE TEMPTATIONS. BUT THE SONG HE WROTE FOR DAVID RUFFIN — THE ONE HE NEVER RELEASED — HAS SAT IN HIS DESK DRAWER FOR 34 YEARS. “IT WAS TOO HONEST. AND NOW IT’S TOO LATE.” At Motown in the 1960s, Smokey Robinson was the man behind the magic. He wrote hits like other people write grocery lists — effortlessly, endlessly. But when he wrote “My Girl,” he knew exactly whose voice it needed. David Ruffin’s. David sang it like a man who’d been waiting his whole life for that melody. It became The Temptations’ signature. It became Motown’s crown jewel. It became David’s identity — and eventually his cage. Fame broke David the way it breaks everyone who burns too bright. The drugs came. The Temptations let him go. The phone calls from Smokey went unanswered. Sometime in the early ’70s, Smokey sat alone in Studio A at Hitsville and recorded a demo. No label. No title. Just a voice and a piano and a song meant for one man. He put the tape in his desk drawer and never played it for anyone. On June 1, 1991, David Ruffin collapsed outside a hospital in Philadelphia. He was 50. The voice that turned “My Girl” into a prayer was gone. Smokey didn’t speak publicly for days. When asked about the demo years later, he said only this: “It was too honest. And now it’s too late. Some songs are meant to be heard by one person. And that person is gone.” The drawer is still closed. Some music isn’t meant for the world. It’s meant for a friend who left before you could press play.

Smokey Robinson, David Ruffin, and the Song That Never Left the Drawer At Motown in the 1960s, songs were not…

ELTON JOHN DIDN’T PERFORM FOR 2 WEEKS AFTER GEORGE MICHAEL DIED ON CHRISTMAS 2016 — THE ONLY TIME IN 50 YEARS HE WENT SILENT. “I COULDN’T SING KNOWING THE MOST BEAUTIFUL VOICE I’D EVER HEARD JUST WENT QUIET.” They met when George was still a kid from North London with too much talent and not enough armor. Elton saw himself in those eyes — the gift, the loneliness, the weight of being adored by millions and understood by no one. For 30 years, Elton watched. Celebrated. Worried. He called George more times than George ever called back. He begged him to take care of himself. George always said, “I will, I will.” On December 25, 2016, George Michael was found dead at his home in Oxfordshire. He was 53. Elton cancelled everything. For two weeks — the only two weeks in a 50-year career — his piano stayed closed. No concerts. No statements. No interviews. When he finally returned to the stage, he sat down, placed his hands on the keys, and played the opening notes of “Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me.” The song they’d sung together at Wembley in 1991. 72,000 people. Two voices that shook the rafters. Now there was only one. And halfway through, Elton stopped and whispered: “I couldn’t save him. And I’ll never forgive myself for that.” Some duets are immortal. Some silences are permanent. And some Christmas nights never stop hurting.

When George Michael Died, Elton John Faced a Silence Music Could Not Easily Fill Christmas Day in 2016 did not…

You Missed

SMOKEY ROBINSON WROTE “MY GIRL” FOR THE TEMPTATIONS. BUT THE SONG HE WROTE FOR DAVID RUFFIN — THE ONE HE NEVER RELEASED — HAS SAT IN HIS DESK DRAWER FOR 34 YEARS. “IT WAS TOO HONEST. AND NOW IT’S TOO LATE.” At Motown in the 1960s, Smokey Robinson was the man behind the magic. He wrote hits like other people write grocery lists — effortlessly, endlessly. But when he wrote “My Girl,” he knew exactly whose voice it needed. David Ruffin’s. David sang it like a man who’d been waiting his whole life for that melody. It became The Temptations’ signature. It became Motown’s crown jewel. It became David’s identity — and eventually his cage. Fame broke David the way it breaks everyone who burns too bright. The drugs came. The Temptations let him go. The phone calls from Smokey went unanswered. Sometime in the early ’70s, Smokey sat alone in Studio A at Hitsville and recorded a demo. No label. No title. Just a voice and a piano and a song meant for one man. He put the tape in his desk drawer and never played it for anyone. On June 1, 1991, David Ruffin collapsed outside a hospital in Philadelphia. He was 50. The voice that turned “My Girl” into a prayer was gone. Smokey didn’t speak publicly for days. When asked about the demo years later, he said only this: “It was too honest. And now it’s too late. Some songs are meant to be heard by one person. And that person is gone.” The drawer is still closed. Some music isn’t meant for the world. It’s meant for a friend who left before you could press play.